Fiche de révision : Athens and the Elgin Marbles

Plan du Cours

  1. Athens and Its Historical Legacy
  2. Athenian Democracy and Its Institutions
  3. The Limits of Athenian Citizenship
  4. The Marbles Under Ottoman Rule
  5. Elgin’s Removal and Its Justifications
  6. Greek Claims for Repatriation
  7. The Marbles and Cultural Identity

1. Athens and Its Historical Legacy

★ À maîtriser

  • Athens is described as the birthplace of democracy and Western culture, whose arts, science, architecture and language continue to influence the present.

Compléments

  • Renaissance people regarded Athens as the Golden Age of civilisation.

2. Athenian Democracy and Its Institutions

Notions clés & Définitions

  • Democracy : Democracy means that the people rule or govern the city; the word is Greek in origin.

★ À maîtriser

  • Solon, Cleisthenes and Pericles are identified as leaders who reorganised Athenian society to promote equality among citizens, called isonomia.

  • The Ekklesia was an assembly where all men could attend and vote, and it met on the Pnyx, Athens’s second hill after the Acropolis.

  • The Boulè consisted of 500 men who wrote laws and prepared the work of the Ekklesia.

Compléments

  • The Heliae was a court that judged citizens.

📌 A person accused of threatening Athenian democracy could be exiled after a vote for 10 years, a punishment called ostracism.

3. The Limits of Athenian Citizenship

★ À maîtriser

  • Only 10% of Athens’s inhabitants were citizens: free men over 18 who had completed military service, called the Ephebia.

  • Groups excluded from Athenian citizenship included :

    • women
    • children
    • slaves
    • foreigners called metics

Compléments

📌 Athenian democracy was considered revolutionary for its time, but its restricted citizenship differed greatly from modern democracies.

Astuce mémo

Citizens could participate; women, children, slaves and metics could not.

4. The Marbles Under Ottoman Rule

★ À maîtriser

  • In the 19th century, Greece was not an independent country and was under Ottoman rule.

  • Fighting between Greeks and Turks in Athens led to destruction on the Acropolis and in the Parthenon, damaging the marbles and frieze.

Compléments

  • The procession included :
    • citizens
    • magistrates
    • horsemen
    • hoplites
    • young women

Astuce mémo

Ottoman rule and fighting → damage to the Acropolis sculptures.

5. Elgin’s Removal and Its Justifications

★ À maîtriser

  • Lord Elgin, the British ambassador, removed the marbles from the Acropolis under what he claimed was permission from the Ottoman authorities; he did not buy them from the Ottoman government.

  • Elgin argued that removing the sculptures would preserve them from destruction and save what remained from being ground into lime for construction.

  • Elgin claimed that he had legal permission from the Ottoman government to retrieve the marbles, but the legality could be disputed because Greek authorities were not consulted.

Compléments

📌 Elgin’s claim that the marbles were taken for the world weakens his argument because it implies that any country could keep them, while his belief in Britain’s cultural superiority suggests an imperial motive.

  • The British Museum also contains non-British artefacts, including the Rosetta Stone, and is presented as a place associated with British imperialism; the reconstructed Ishtar Gate is in the Pergamon Museum in Berlin, not the British Museum.

Astuce mémo

Preservation was Elgin’s stated reason; imperial prestige complicates that claim.

6. Greek Claims for Repatriation

★ À maîtriser

  • Displaying the sculptures outside Athens is argued to strip them of artistic, historical and civic meaning; their presentation in a room reproducing the Parthenon is used as evidence of this loss of cultural integrity.

  • The Acropolis Museum opened in 2009 and is presented as evidence that Greece can preserve its monuments and cultural artefacts; it is newer than the British Museum, which dates from the 19th century.

Compléments

  • The Greek case argues that the Ottoman government’s permission was obtained without consulting Greek authorities and invokes a 1970 United Nations prohibition on the illegal export of cultural artefacts from their countries of origin.

  • The Greek legal case is also weakened because there were no independent Greek national authorities when Elgin removed the marbles in the early 19th century, the British Museum acquired the marbles from Elgin rather than from the Greeks or Ottomans, and the British Museum Act 1963 restricts the disposal of objects in its collection, subject to limited exceptions.

7. The Marbles and Cultural Identity

★ À maîtriser

  • The marbles symbolise civilisation and Greek national identity, making their ownership more than a diplomatic controversy.

Compléments

  • The debate over the marbles raises the question: “Who owns the past?”

Teste tes connaissances

Teste tes connaissances sur Athens and the Elgin Marbles avec 18 questions à choix multiples et corrections détaillées.

1. Quels domaines de la culture occidentale, associés à Athènes, continuent d’influencer le présent ?

2. Comment les penseurs de la Renaissance considéraient-ils Athènes ?

Faire le QCM →

Révisez avec les flashcards

Mémorisez les concepts clés de Athens and the Elgin Marbles avec 39 flashcards interactives.

What is Athens described as the birthplace of?

Democracy and Western culture.

Which aspects of Athens continue to influence the present?

Its arts, science, architecture and language.

What does democracy mean?

The people rule or govern the city.

Voir les flashcards →

Cours similaires

Crée tes propres fiches de révision

Importe ton cours et l'IA génère fiches, QCM et flashcards en 30 secondes.

Générateur de fiches