Fiche de révision : Elizabeth II and the Commonwealth

Plan du Cours

  1. Elizabeth II’s Commitment to the Commonwealth
  2. The Monarchy and Commonwealth Leadership
  3. Racial Legacies and Commonwealth Principles
  4. South Africa and Apartheid
  5. Commonwealth Opposition to Apartheid
  6. Thatcher, Sanctions and the Queen
  7. The Queen’s Visit to Ghana

Repères chronologiques

  1. 1910The South African Act formed South Africa from several states, and the country entered the Commonwealth.
  2. 1948The National Party, which supported white supremacy and separation between white and Black communities, was elected in South Africa.
  3. 1961South Africa withdrew its application to remain in the Commonwealth rather than face pressure to change its apartheid policies.
  4. 1971The Singapore Declaration committed Commonwealth leaders to defending individual rights and opposing racial discrimination.
  5. 1977The Gleneagles Agreement established a sporting ban on South Africa, excluding it from international competitions including cricket and rugby.
  6. 1979Margaret Thatcher became Prime Minister of the United Kingdom and opposed economic sanctions against South Africa.
  7. 1979Elizabeth II travelled to Zambia against Thatcher’s advice and presided over the signing of the Lusaka Declaration on racism and discrimination.
  8. 1989F. W. de Klerk was elected, Nelson Mandela was released, and apartheid was abolished.
  9. 1994Nelson Mandela became President of South Africa, which rejoined the Commonwealth after his election.
  10. 2018Commonwealth leaders agreed that Charles would be the next Head of the Commonwealth, which was seen as a gesture of gratitude towards Elizabeth II.

1. Elizabeth II’s Commitment to the Commonwealth

★ À maîtriser

  • Queen Elizabeth II said that the Commonwealth should represent association, not the domination of one country over others.

  • Elizabeth II visited nearly every Commonwealth country, often more than once, to maintain personal relationships with their leaders and citizens.

  • On her 21st birthday, Elizabeth II pledged that her whole life would be devoted to serving her people and the “great imperial family” to which they belonged.

Compléments

  • Sir Philip Moore, her private secretary from 1977 to 1986, estimated that Elizabeth II devoted half of her time to the Commonwealth.

  • Elizabeth II and Nelson Mandela were close friends, used each other’s first names, and frequently spoke on the phone.

  • Elizabeth II celebrated her 21st birthday in South Africa during her first journey outside Great Britain, travelling with her parents and sister.

  • During a Commonwealth trip with Prince Philip, Elizabeth learned that her father had died, became Queen, and cut short the journey that was to include Australia and New Zealand after a tour of Africa.

2. The Monarchy and Commonwealth Leadership

Notions clés & Définitions

  • Head of the Commonwealth : The Head of the Commonwealth is a non-hereditary role, and member states may choose someone other than the British monarch to hold it.

Points essentiels

  • Immediately after her coronation, Elizabeth II undertook a five-and-a-half-month tour of Commonwealth countries by plane and ship.

  • Elizabeth II’s tour was the first time a British monarch had circled the globe.

  • David Adamson argued that the Commonwealth enhanced the Crown’s distinctiveness and helped protect the monarchy from domestic criticism, including criticism of its cost to taxpayers.

Astuce mémo

The Queen was a British head of state; Head of the Commonwealth was a separate, non-hereditary role.

3. Racial Legacies and Commonwealth Principles

★ À maîtriser

  • The 1991 Harare Declaration condemned racial prejudice and intolerance as a threat to healthy development and racial discrimination as an unmitigated evil.

  • After the Second World War, the Commonwealth had to adapt a system originally designed in favour of white communities to include newly independent Asian, Oceanian and African states.

Compléments

  • The Harare Declaration opposed all forms of racial oppression and committed its signatories to human dignity and equality.

  • In “The White Man’s Burden” (1899), Rudyard Kipling portrayed white people as having a moral duty to rule non-white people, described as “half devil and half child.”

📌 For the Commonwealth to succeed as an association of nations, its members had to respect one another.

Astuce mémo

Colonial racial hierarchies → the challenge of building a multiracial association.

4. South Africa and Apartheid

★ À maîtriser

  • South Africa’s population was classified as :
    • Whites (13%)
    • Blacks (76%)
    • Coloureds (8.5%)
    • Asians (2.5%)

Compléments

  • In 1961, South Africa became a republic and left the Commonwealth; apartheid had been introduced in 1948.

  • Apartheid prohibited interracial marriages and separated the classified communities.

  • South Africa was the only country with a non-white majority in which non-white people could not vote, except in Cape Colony, where Coloured people had voting rights.

  • After apartheid, South Africa established redistribution programmes and affirmative action, but continued to face unemployment, poverty and crime.

5. Commonwealth Opposition to Apartheid

★ À maîtriser

  • If South Africa had remained in the Commonwealth, African and Asian members might have left, newly independent African states might not have joined, and the organisation could have become predominantly white again.

Compléments

  • Most Commonwealth countries, particularly Nigeria and Ghana, sought to oppose South Africa’s racist policies through diplomatic isolation and economic sanctions.

  • The Commonwealth opposed apartheid because racial discrimination contradicted its principles of equality, friendship and equal treatment among members.

  • South Africa’s refusal to accept non-white diplomats from other Commonwealth countries was a key reason members turned against it.

6. Thatcher, Sanctions and the Queen

★ À maîtriser

📌 Elizabeth II was head of state in the United Kingdom, where she had to support British policy, but her role as Head of the Commonwealth was purely symbolic and gave her no constitutional functions.

Compléments

  • Thatcher argued that economic sanctions would be ineffective and could endanger South Africa’s Black population.

  • In 1986, Thatcher refused to impose sanctions on South Africa, and some Commonwealth leaders threatened to leave the organisation.

  • On 20 July 1986, the Sunday Times published an article alleging that Elizabeth II was upset with Thatcher, although the extent of their tensions remained unclear.

  • Kenneth Kaunda said that Elizabeth II had saved the Commonwealth from breaking apart by allowing people to infer that she disapproved of Thatcher’s position.

  • The sovereign regularly gives a Commonwealth Day message and a Christmas message in their capacity as Head of the Commonwealth, on their own responsibility rather than as monarch of the United Kingdom or another realm.

📌 Before the sovereign sends Commonwealth messages, they are shown to the British Prime Minister as a courtesy, and the sovereign must avoid statements that could upset ministers or disrupt constitutional relations.

Astuce mémo

Thatcher opposed sanctions; the Commonwealth’s principles opposed racial discrimination.

7. The Queen’s Visit to Ghana

★ À maîtriser

  • In 1961, Elizabeth II made an official visit to Ghana despite warnings from the British press and concerns expressed by Winston Churchill.

  • On 18 November 1961, Elizabeth II danced a waltz with Kwame Nkrumah at a farewell ball in Ghana, while Prince Philip danced with Fatia Nkrumah.

  • Elizabeth II’s visits and diplomatic presence helped maintain Commonwealth relationships, making her an ambassador for the United Kingdom as well as a symbolic figure.

Compléments

  • Elizabeth II was concerned that Kwame Nkrumah’s growing ties with Moscow might lead Ghana to leave the Commonwealth during the Cold War.

  • The photograph of Elizabeth II dancing with Nkrumah showed a white Queen and a Black president dancing as equals while segregation remained prevalent in the United States and apartheid had led South Africa to leave the Commonwealth.

  • The widely circulated photograph symbolised the success of the visit for both the United Kingdom and Ghana.

Astuce mémo

The Queen and Nkrumah waltzing as equals at the farewell ball.

Tableaux de synthèse

Elizabeth II’s roles and constraints

RoleFunctionConstraint
British head of statePromoted British policiesConstitutional relationship with ministers
Head of the CommonwealthSymbolic leadership and messagesNo constitutional functions; had to avoid political statements

Teste tes connaissances

Teste tes connaissances sur Elizabeth II and the Commonwealth avec 18 questions à choix multiples et corrections détaillées.

1. Quelle conception Elizabeth II défendait-elle pour les relations entre les pays du Commonwealth ?

2. Une équipe souhaite comprendre comment Elizabeth II entretenait des liens personnels avec les habitants et les dirigeants du Commonwealth. Quelle pratique correspond à son engagement ?

Faire le QCM →

Révisez avec les flashcards

Mémorisez les concepts clés de Elizabeth II and the Commonwealth avec 54 flashcards interactives.

What should the Commonwealth represent, according to Elizabeth II?

An association, not the domination of one country over others.

How often did Elizabeth II visit nearly every Commonwealth country?

Often more than once.

What did Elizabeth II pledge to devote her whole life to on her 21st birthday?

Serving her people and the “great imperial family” to which they belonged.

Voir les flashcards →

Cours similaires

Crée tes propres fiches de révision

Importe ton cours et l'IA génère fiches, QCM et flashcards en 30 secondes.

Générateur de fiches